Week six: Reviewing peers Artwork

2. When looking at Project #1: (Elements and Principles), did you agree with the element or principle the artist listed with the images? Did you see other elements and principles in the images?
(http://clare-castelletti.blogspot.com/2011/06/slideshow_11.html). Slide number 11 of your first project it does a good job at accomplishing your task.  I saw multiple elements and principles with this; through pattern, repetition and shapes.
(http://aed-200-adrienne.blogspot.com/)
For her project number one I did not see any project 1 listing
3. When looking at Project #2: Where there any images in the Peer Blogs the same as your own? If yes, what were they? Where the reasons the image was selected the same or different as your own?
-(http://clare-castelletti.blogspot.com/2011/06/slideshow_11.html)No, there were not any images that were the same as other students mostly due to the fact that I live four hours and thirty minutes away from buffalo.
(http://aed-200-adrienne.blogspot.com/ )
No, there were not any images that were the same as other students mostly due to the fact that I live four hours and thirty minutes away from buffalo.
4. Where there any images that your Peers selected that pique your interest now? If yes, what are they and what is your connection with them? What would you want to know about them?.
(http://clare-castelletti.blogspot.com/2011/06/slideshow_11.html).   For project number 1 Nothing here was of any interest of me because it seems as though she just casually glanced through her camera for photos that he/she already had and used them for a majority of the project.  Although I guess its possible for snow in june if you live in Alaska.
(http://aed-200-adrienne.blogspot.com/)
Again I could not find a project number 1 on his/her blog
5. What do you think about  the process of reading your peers reflection? Do you find this to be a valuable in your learning.
No I do not find them valuable.  Art, like music, is more of a taste than something that can be reviewed.  Of course there are simple things, like most pop songs recently with a steady house bass that everyone enjoys.  Does that make it a work of art; no it does not.  Great works of art will last hundreds of years.  Most of what is popular nowadays will not.  So having people I don’t know review my artwork has no impact on me.
6. Check your Blog and read comments posted by your Peers. Do you find their comments helpful?
To be honest im not entirely sure why we had to review each others projects.  Chances are that none of us in the class know as much about art as you.  So why would we have anything more than our honest opinions of whether or not something is “good” or not.  I don’t think anyone can successfully critique art when they have only dealt with it for a couple months.  This is just my opinion though.  So my answer is no, I don’t find my peers comments helpful.